Catering
Whether you’re planning a birthday, anniversary, Bris, Bar/Bat Mitzvah, Shiva, wedding, post-wedding brunch, or just a gathering of friends or family, Shelsky’s catering is here to help.
TO PLACE YOUR ORDER OR ANY INQUIRIES PLEASE EMAIL
[email protected]
Shelsky’s requires a minimum of 24-hours notice for all catering orders.
Minimum order for deliveries: Brooklyn – $150 | Manhattan – $300
Thank you for reaching out!
We will contact you soon.
Shelsky’s Catering Inquiry
Ordering for a Party of 40 or less?
Order NowOrdering for a Party of 41+?
Get Started
Smoked Fish Platters
Shelsky's Smoked Salmon Platter
Includes
-
Hand-sliced eastern Gaspé Nova
-
Assorted Shelsky's bagels
-
Plain & scallion cream cheese
-
Sliced red onions & capers
Supplements
-
Sliced tomatoes, cucumbers, and lemons
(per person) $1 -
Scottish smoked salmon
(per person) $3 -
OraKing smoked salmon
(per person) $4 -
Salmon roe
(per person) $6
Shelsky's Salmon Trio Platter
Includes
-
Hand-sliced Scottish salmon
-
House-cured gravlax
-
Pastrami smoked salmon
-
Assorted Shelsky's bagels
-
Plain & scallion cream cheese
-
Sliced red onions and capers
Supplements
-
Sliced tomatoes, cucumbers, and lemons
(per person) $1 -
Salmon roe
(per person) $6
Smoked Goodness Platter
Includes
-
Hand-sliced eastern Gaspé Nova
-
Smoked wild Alaskan sable
-
Rich kippered (baked) salmon
-
Whole boned-out Lake Michigan whitefish
-
Assorted Shelsky's bagels
-
Plain & scallion cream cheese
-
Sliced red onions and capers
Supplements
-
Sliced tomatoes, cucumbers, and lemons
(per person) $1 -
Salmon roe
(per person) $6
Grand Smoked Plateau
Includes
-
Hand-sliced eastern Gaspé Nova
-
Scottish smoked salmon
-
Pastrami smoked salmon
-
Whole boned-out Lake Michigan whitefish
-
House-pickled herring with cream sauce and onions
-
Assorted Shelsky's bagels
-
Plain & scallion cream cheese
-
Sliced red onions and capers
-
Sliced tomatoes, cucumbers, and lemons
Supplements
-
Salmon roe
(per person) $6
Shelsky's Salads and Schmears Platter
Includes
-
Your choice of 6 of the following salads:
-
Shelsky's smoked whitefish salad
-
Baked salmon salad
-
Seriously great tuna salad
-
Smoked bluefish salad with roasted hazelnuts, oranges, and fennel
-
Pickled herring salad
-
Chicken salad with grapes and pecans
-
Egg salad with cornichons
-
Traditional cucumber salad
-
Citrus-roasted beet salad
-
Chopped liver
-
Delicatessen potato salad
-
Coleslaw
-
Macaroni salad
-
Health salad
-
Riesling-braised sauerkraut
-
Assorted pickles (half sour, full sour, & pickled green tomatoes)
Supplements
-
Salmon Roe
(per person) $6
Fruit And Platters Of Sweet Things
Fresh Fruit Platter
Diced fresh "all-year-round" fruit and a selection of the freshest seasonal fruit the market has to offer
Variations
Supplements
Salad of Mixed Fresh Fruit
Medley of only the freshest fruit cut into bite-sized pieces, served with fresh-picked mint
Supplements
-
Bowl of schlag
(per person) $16
House Granola and Yogurt
Truly AMAZING granola served with labneh and fresh blueberries
Shelsky's Sweets Platter
A bountiful platter of assorted homemade rugelach, chocolate babka, honey cake, gooey coconut macaroons, and chocolate chip cookies with Maldon sea salt
Continental Pastry Basket
Selection of croissants, almond croissants, pain au chocolat, lemon-poppy muffins, pain au raisin, and blueberry scones, served with Kate's creamery butter, clotted cream, and Sarabeth's fruit preserves
Smoked & Cured Fish Sandwich Platter
Member of the Tribe (The Classic)
Hand-sliced Eastern Gaspé Nova and your choice of plain or scallion cream cheese,served on a bagel or bialy
Brooklyn Native
Smoked whitefish salad, Eastern Gaspé Nova, pickled herring, and sour pickles, served on a bagel or bialy
Brooklyn Transplant
Kippered salmon, pickled herring salad, apple horseradish sauce, and plain cream cheese, served on your choice of rye or pumpernickel bread
The Peter Shelsky
Eastern Gaspé Nova, wild Alaskan sable, pickled herring with cream sauce and onions, and scallion cream cheese, served on your choice of a bagel or bialy
The Great Gatsby
Pastrami-smoked salmon, horseradish cream cheese, honey mustard, and thinly-sliced red onions served on carawy-seeded rye
The Holy Mackerel
Rhode Island smoked peppered mackerel, cucumber salad, and vegetable cream cheese served on a bagel or bialy
Spicy Shrimp Roll
Spicy shrimp salad, iceburg lettuce, and butter served on an onion roll
The Fishless
Sour pickled tomato, fresh tomato, thinly-sliced red onions, fresh jalapeños, cilantro, apple horserdaish sauce, and mayonnaise, served on a bagel or bialy
The Turboff
Eastern Gaspé Nova, baked salmon salad, thinly-sliced red onions, and horseradish cream cheese served on a bagel or bialy
The Clementine
House-cured gravlax, tomato, thinly-sliced red onion, capers, and a squeeze of lemon served on a bagel or bialy
The Newhouse
Wild Alaskan smoked sable, scallion cream cheese, and tomato served on a bagel or bialy
The Fancy Pants
Fancy lake sturgeon, house-cured gravlax, tomato, thinly-sliced red onion, and plain cream cheese served on a bagel or bialy
Osetra's Momma
Fancy lake sturgeon, thinly-sliced red onion, and butter served on a bagel or bialy
El Vicente
Fancy lake sturgeon, tomato, fresh jalapeños, and plain cream cheese served on a bagel or bialy
Spicy Red, White, or Blue
Your choice of baked salmon salad, smoked whitefish salad, or smoked bluefish salad topped with cucmber salad and sriracha served on your choice of rye or pumpernickel
The Tribute
Smoked whitefish salad, wasabi tobiko, and horseradish cream cheese on a bagel or bialy
Tuna Spicy Super Funk
Seriously great tuna salad, fresh jalapeños, Malaysian chili sambal (with fermented shrimp), and crispy fried onions on your choice of rye or pumpernickel
Simple Schmear Sandwich Platter
Butter
Plain cream cheese
Scallion cream cheese
Lox cream cheese
Horseradish cream cheese
Vegetable cream cheese
Sichuan chili crisp cream cheese
Tofu plain cream cheese
Tofu scallion cream cheese
Smoked whitefish salad
Baked salmon salad
Seriously great tuna salad
Smoked bluefish salad with hazelnuts, oranges, and fennel
Egg salad with cornichons
Pickled herring salad
Chicken salad with grapes and pecans
Chopped liver
Shelsky's Deli Meat Platter
Shelsky's Deli Meat Platter
Includes 2 sides of your choice, assorted pickles, sliced rye and pumpernickel, spicy brown deli mustard, and Russian dressing
Variations and Modifiers
- Choice of 3 meats $33.99
- Choice of 4 meats $36.99
- Choice of 2 sides
Meat Choices
- Pastrami
- Corned Beef
- Pickled Tongue
- Roast Beef
- Roast Turkey
Side Choices
- Coleslaw
- Health Salad
- Potato Salad
- Macaroni Salad
- Riesling-braised Sauerkraut
Supplement
-
Add Swiss Cheese
(per person) $2
Delicatessen Sandwich Platter
Pastrami sandwich
Our pastrami is slowly cured with a special blend of spices. It is then smoked over hard wood and steamed to tender awesomeness. Served on rye with deli mustard
Corned beef sandwich
Our ccorned beef is cured gently for a week to ensure the full complexity of the special cure is in every bite. Steamed and sliced, our corned beef sandwich is mind-meltingly delicious. Served on rye with deli mustard
Shelsky's Roast Beef Roll
Our homemade roast beef nestled on an onion roll with butter, Dijon mustard, and crispy fried onions
Shelsky's Roast Turkey Sandwich
Our homemade roast turkey served on rye with coleslaw, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing
Pickled Tongue Sandwich
Peter Shelsky's childhood favorite.... Corned beef tongue seved on rye with deli mustard
Mr. Goldstein Special
Chopped liver and apple horseradish sauce served on an onion roll
Crudités Platter
Crudités Platter
A bountiful platter of fresh crudités served with fines herbes fromage blanc dipping sauce
Beverage Services
Coffee & Tea Service
Includes milk, half & half, oat milk, Sugar in the Raw, sweetener, cups, sleeves, lids, and stirrers
-
Box of freshly brewed hot Ashlawn Farm Coffee
$35 -
Ashlawn Farm Hot Coffee Service (For 60+ People)
(per person) $4*Percolating coffee urn rental – $40
-
Selection of fine hot teas from Le Palais des Thés
(per box) $36 -
Box of cold-brewed Ashlawn Farm Coffee
(per box) $60
Juice, Soda, & Water
Includes cupsVariations and Modifiers
-
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice (per person) $4
-
Canned Seltzer (ea.) $1.25
-
Topo Chico Sparklng Water (ea.) $2.50
-
Poland Spring Water (ea.) $1.50
-
Can of Diet Coke (ea.) $1.50
-
Bottle of Mexican Coke (ea.) $2.25
-
Can of Dr. Brown's Soda (ea.) $1.50
Flavors:
Black Cherry, Diet Black Cherry, Cream, Diet Cream, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Cel-Ray
-
McClure's Bloody Mary Mix (jar) $12.99
*Prices and availability subject to change without notice.
Concierge Event Planning Services
You’re event should be worry free. Let Shelsky’s take the worry off your plate.
Party Rentals
Skip the rental delivery fees, headaches, and expense of the large party rental companies.
Cost of the rentals + 5% of subtotal menu cost
Wine and Alcohol Partnership
We work exclusively with the fine folks at Brooklyn Wine Exchange to bring you fine wines and liquors at reduced pricing.
Cost of the wine and/or alcohol + 1% of subtotal menu cost
Flower Partnership
We work exclusively with Eka at Edelweiss Floral Atelier to bring beautiful arrangements to life at your event within a budget that works for you.
Cost of the flowers + 1% of subtotal menu cost